Does the Nupes program comprise the phrase “ban” 30 occasions and “taxation” 20 occasions, as Emmanuel Macron states?

As legislative elections strategy, Emmanuel Macron faces his opponents. In an interview with the regional press, printed on Thursday 2 June, the President of the Republic chastised the proposals of the New Ecological and Social Standard Union. “I’ve learn the Nupes program. They point out the phrase ‘taxation’ 20 occasions and the phrase ‘ban’ 30 occasions, which provides a fairly clear thought of ​​the spirit of this system.”attacked the top of state.

Within the course of, the topic was taken up by members of the presidential majority. Typically with barely completely different numbers. For instance, the brand new Minister for Ecological Transition, Amélie de Montchalin identified “35 times the word prohibition”. Olivier Véran, now Minister accountable for Relations with Parliament, counted on his half “41 occasions” phrases “prohibited or prohibited or forbidden”.

The chief of La France insoumise “proposes a society the place both all the things is prohibited or all the things is organized”, for his half, Christophe Castaner, chief of the LREM deputies, gained. Behind these figures, what does the left-wing alliance program actually envision?

A key phrase search within the Nupes program makes it doable to confirm that it really comprises the phrases “ban” or “prohibit” 41 occasions, as acknowledged by Olivier Véran. Nonetheless, not all of those occasions relate to the proposals of the Left Alliance. The phrase “prohibition” seems for instance within the reference to the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons of the United Nations, which entered into drive in 2021. As well as, some Nupes proposals are talked about a number of occasions in this system, subsequently some repetitions.

In whole, in keeping with calculations by franceinfo, the Nupes program consists of 36 completely different proposals that point out “bans”. A determine fairly near that proposed by Amélie de Montchalin. However the Nupes typically needs to bolster sure already current prohibitions, to be able to apply them “In actuality” The place is it “instantly”. That is what the left-wing coalition needs “Instantly ban single-use plastics”. In actual fact, it’s a query of dashing up occasions, on condition that France has already set itself the purpose of banning them “by 2040”. A voted “ban” … throughout Emmanuel Macron’s first five-year time period.

Likewise, Nupes is dedicated to actually prohibit the rental of thermal colanders “. A regulation on this spirit was additionally adopted throughout Emmanuel Macron’s tenure, but it surely doesn’t have an effect on all energy-intensive properties. Concerning animal abuse, this system additionally mentions the ban on sure practices, resembling battery hens and rabbits, or the grinding of chicks. Nonetheless, a decree, adopted by the earlier authorities and printed in February, already plans to ban the elimination of male chicks in egg manufacturing chains by the tip of the 12 months.

Furthermore, these numerous figures hammered by the president and his supporters don’t present any info on the extent of the “prohibitions” defended by Nupes. Intimately, sixteen of them are listed within the chapter “Ecology, biodiversity, local weather, widespread items and vitality”. It consists of the tip of promoting for services that emit extra greenhouse gases, the ban “instant” glyphosate, ban “emergency” meals components “extra controversial”the tip of intensive farming or the prohibition of sure searching practices, resembling searching with canines.

Different proposals goal firms and financial actors, banning them “redundancies on the inventory alternate” The place is it “financial redundancies by firms that pay dividends or obtain public assist”. Nupes additionally defends the ban on “golden parachute”, these exit bonuses paid to firm administrators. Elected officers and senior state officers are additionally focused by the ban “items to parliamentarians, members of the federal government and their cupboards” it is the tip revolving door, which permits administrative elites to pursue careers within the non-public sector.

As for the phrases “tax”, “tax” or “repair”, they’re talked about 18 occasions within the Nupes program. A quantity near the 20 occurrences cited by Emmanuel Macron. Once more, nevertheless, some measures seem a number of occasions. Not all of them even represent tax creations. Typically it’s a query of adjusting the arrow of an already current tax, resembling “reserving the apprenticeship tax to public our bodies”.

And as for the bans, the quantitative argument doesn’t permit us to understand the true content material of the left-wing alliance program in fiscal issues. If we take a better take a look at this system, a lot of the proposals are a part of the chapter “Wealth Sharing and Tax Justice”and extra exactly of the field “make a tax revolution”. The Nupes is contemplating specifically from “rI discovered the property tax to make it progressive “ you hate “tax firms that took benefit of the well being disaster and the implications of the Ukrainian disaster”.

This system additionally mentions the abolition of the “flat tax” launched by Emmanuel Macron, in addition to the reinstatement of the wealth tax (ISF), abolished beneath the primary mandate of Head of State. The textual content additionally mentions the “exit tax” on the capital positive aspects of taxpayers leaving France, the abolition of which had lengthy been thought-about by Emmanuel Macron, earlier than being definitively decreased.

Ultimately, the Nupes hear “rbegin the tax undertaking “ digital giants. A undertaking began within the earlier 5 years. She needs too “to introduce a big tax on monetary transactions”. A theme that has divided the member states of the European Union for ten years. Within the earlier 5 years, the French government had proven itself in favor of the institution of this tax, however in a minimal model.

Leave a Comment